I'm always loathe to give a product one star, so I gave two, but I wanted to give one out of sheer disappointment. I have a pair of very well-worn (Classic) Crocs that are 13+ years old... got them sometime in '07. They still serve my purposes perfectly well, but I wanted to replace them with some ...that had holes on top, but not around the outer edge. The Bayaband has a nice look, and is supposed to have the same fit as the Classics (both say "Roomy - Our most generous, roomy fit"), so I chose those. Well, I don't know how the modern Classics fit compared to my old Classics, but these Bayabands are SO much smaller than my old Classics. They are the same size (8), but the new pair is much shorter and much narrower - I will include a photo. Crocs are meant to fit your feet a certain way.... very loosely. It's part of the magic of Crocs. You should be able to put your foot in, and the inside will not touch your foot on the sides or the back or the front, yet it stays on your foot when you walk thanks to the strap. Basically, it should feel like it's too big. It's not. It's supposed to be like walking barefoot without a confining shoe, except that you're walking on a comfy cloud of funky rubber stuff. Oh wait, there's the other problem. My old Crocs were amazingly(!) comfortable when I bought them... like walking on a plush, bouncy cloud. After 13 years, they have certainly flattened some, but are still very comfortable. In fact, they are more comfortable than the brand new ones, which mostly just feel like a regular shoe, not a plush, bouncy cloud. Either the material isn't the same, or they're not using enough of it for the bottoms. Which wouldn't surprise me, given how much they've cut down the rest of the shoe. Since these are too small, I'm going to try to exchange them for the next size up and hope for the best. I have a feeling that even the next size up sadly won't fit like my old ones.